| Season | League | Avg Att |
| 1. 1977-78 | Division Three | 12,272 |
| 2. 2024-25 | League One | 11,415 |
| 3. 1947-48 | Division Three (North) | 11,168 |
| 4. 1961-62 | Division Four | 10,861 |
| 5. 1956-57 | Division Three (North) | 10,731 |
| 6. 1978-79 | Division Two | 10,711 |
| 7. 1962-63 | Division Three | 10,696 |
| 8. 2023-24 | League Two | 10,631 |
| 9. 1952-53 | Division Three (North) | 10,009 |
| 10. 1948-49 | Division Three (North) | 9,751 |
| 11. 2022-23 | National League | 9,625 |
| 12. 1958-59 | Division Three | 9,524 |
| 13. 1953-54 | Division Three (North) | 9,514 |
| 14. 1979-80 | Division Two | 9,455 |
| 15. 1969-70 | Division Four | 9,245 |
| 16. 1959-60 | Division Three | 9,143 |
| 17. 1950-51 | Division Three (North) | 8,808 |
| 18. 1946-47 | Division Three (North) | 8,732 |
| 19. 1976-77 | Division Three | 8,731 |
| 20. 1957-58 | Division Three (North) | 8,463 |
| 21. 1966-67 | Division Four | 8,414 |
| 22. 1951-52 | Division Three (North) | 8,370 |
| 23. 1970-71 | Division Three | 8,289 |
| 24. 1949-50 | Division Three (North) | 8,256 |
| 25. 2021-22 | National League | 7,962 |
| 26. 1955-56 | Division Three (North) | 7,588 |
| 27. 1954-55 | Division Three (North) | 7,369 |
| 28. 1932-33 | Division Three (North) | 7,081 |
| 29. 1963-64 | Division Three | 7,064 |
| 30. 1944-45 | Football Regional League (North Division) | 7,003 |
| 31. 1928-29 | Division Three (North) | 6,846 |
| 32. 1980-81 | Division Two | 6,698 |
| 33. 1967-68 | Division Four | 6,471 |
| 34. 1923-24 | Division Three (North) | 6,307 |
| 35. 1960-61 | Division Four | 6,276 |
| 36. 1945-46 | Third Division North (West Division) | 6,260 |
| 37. 1973-74 | Division Three | 6,123 |
| 38. 1931-32 | Division Three (North) | 6,073 |
| 39. 1971-72 | Division Three | 6,058 |
| 40. 1901-02 | Combination League | 6,000 |
| 41. 1968-69 | Division Four | 5,944 |
| 42. 1933-34 | Division Three (North) | 5,920 |
| 43. 1964-65 | Division Four | 5,915 |
| 44. 1930-31 | Division Three (North) | 5,894 |
| 45. 1936-37 | Division Three (North) | 5,861 |
| 46. 1965-66 | Division Four | 5,805 |
| 47. 1922-23 | Division Three (North) | 5,800 |
| 48. 1925-26 | Division Three (North) | 5,714 |
| 49. 1924-25 | Division Three (North) | 5,707 |
| 50. 1929-30 | Division Three (North) | 5,631 |
| 51. 1921-22 | Division Three (North) | 5,584 |
| 52. 1934-35 | Division Three (North) | 5,547 |
| 53. 1926-27 | Division Three (North) | 5,386 |
| 54. 1972-73 | Division Three | 5,334 |
| 55. 1943-44 | Football Regional League (North Division) | 5,157 |
| 56. 1975-76 | Division Three | 5,031 |
| 57. 1937-38 | Division Three (North) | 4,998 |
| 58. 1927-28 | Division Three (North) | 4,894 |
| 59. 1992-93 | Division Three | 4,826 |
| 60. 2018-19 | National League | 4,798 |
| 61. 2006-07 | League Two | 4,789 |
| 62. 1935-36 | Division Three (North) | 4,772 |
| 63. 1920-21 | Birmingham & District League | 4,671 |
| 64. 2004-05 | League One | 4,640 |
| 65. 1981-82 | Division Two | 4,639 |
| 66. 2017-18 | National League | 4,508 |
| 67. 2015-16 | National League | 4,501 |
| 68. 1938-39 | Division Three (North) | 4,455 |
| 69. 1974-75 | Division Three | 4,337 |
| 70. 2002-03 | Division Three | 4,296 |
| 71. 2007-08 | League Two | 4,284 |
| 72. 2005-06 | League Two | 4,205 |
| 73. 2003-04 | Division Two | 4,193 |
| 74. 1996-97 | Division Two | 4,156 |
| 75. 1889-90 | 4,000 | |
| 76. 1993-94 | Division Two | 3,845 |
| 77. 2011-12 | Conference Premier | 3,838 |
| 78. 1994-95 | Division Two | 3,837 |
| 79. 2016-17 | National League | 3,749 |
| 80. 1997-98 | Division Two | 3,730 |
| 81. 2019-20 | National League | 3,705 |
| 82. 1909-10 | Birmingham & District League | 3,667 |
| 83. 1995-96 | Division Two | 3,641 |
| 84. 1999-00 | Division Two | 3,576 |
| 85. 1998-99 | Division Two | 3,555 |
| 86. 1919-20 | Birmingham & District League | 3,546 |
| 87. 2001-02 | Division Two | 3,464 |
| 88. 1991-92 | Division Four | 3,370 |
| 89. 2012-13 | Conference Premier | 3,350 |
| 90. 1914-15 | Birmingham & District League | 3,200 |
| 91. 1902-03 | Combination League | 3,187 |
| 92. 1908-09 | Birmingham & District League | 3,136 |
| 93. 2008-09 | Conference Premier | 3,128 |
| 94. 1939-40 | Football Regional League (Western Division) | 3,087 |
| 95. 1911-12 | Birmingham & District League | 3,083 |
| 96. 1986-87 | Division Four | 3,071 |
| 97. 2010-11 | Conference Premier | 2,992 |
| 98. 1942-43 | Football Regional League (North Division) | 2,978 |
| 99. 2000-01 | Division Two | 2,976 |
| 100. 2014-15 | Conference Premier | 2,956 |
| 101. 1988-89 | Division Four | 2,875 |
| 102. 2013-14 | Conference Premier | 2,862 |
| 103. 2009-10 | Conference Premier | 2,776 |
| 104. 1913-14 | Birmingham & District League | 2,667 |
| 105. 1982-83 | Division Three | 2,522 |
| 106. 1905-06 | Birmingham & District League | 2,515 |
| 107. 1990-91 | Division Four | 2,477 |
| 108. 1912-13 | Birmingham & District League | 2,350 |
| 109. 1989-90 | Division Four | 2,247 |
| 110. 1907-08 | Birmingham & District League | 2,222 |
| 111. 1910-11 | Birmingham & District League | 2,163 |
| 112. 1987-88 | Division Four | 2,159 |
| 113. 1984-85 | Division Four | 2,076 |
| 114. 1900-01 | Combination League | 2,000 |
| 115. 1883-84 | 2,000 | |
| 116. 1882-83 | 2,000 | |
| 117. 1983-84 | Division Four | 1,988 |
| 118. 1985-86 | Division Four | 1,988 |
| 119. 1906-07 | Birmingham & District League | 1,859 |
| 120. 1941-42 | Football Regional League (North Division) | 1,857 |
| 121. 1893-94 | Combination League | 1,750 |
| 122. 1940-41 | Football Regional League (North Division) | 1,524 |
| 123. 1878-79 | 1,500 | |
| 124. 1892-93 | Combination League | 1,250 |
| 125. 1904-05 | Combination League | 1,100 |
| 126. 1894-95 | Welsh League | 1,000 |
| 127. 1890-91 | Combination League | 975 |
| 128. 1891-92 | Combination League | 913 |
| 129. 1888-89 | 800 | |
| 130. 1879-80 | 800 |